When spouses divorce, they may need to divide assets located in several countries, including foreign apartments and houses, funds held in overseas bank accounts, and investment assets. An important question arises: must the spouses bring proceedings in the country where the assets are located, or can they seek division of those assets before a Russian court?
Russian courts may hear disputes concerning the division of marital property located abroad. The mere fact that real estate or bank accounts are situated in another country does not mean that the dispute falls within the exclusive jurisdiction of foreign courts. The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation has repeatedly confirmed this approach. However, a Russian court's jurisdiction to hear a dispute does not mean that its judgment will automatically be recognised and enforced abroad.
Division of Foreign Real Estate: The Russian Supreme Court's Approach
When determining jurisdiction, it is important to distinguish between disputes over rights in real estate and claims for division of marital property. The former directly concern rights in immovable property, while the latter seek to divide assets acquired during marriage and change the existing regime of joint ownership between spouses. This distinction is of fundamental importance.
In its ruling of 4 December 2018, No. 78-KG18-67, the Russian Supreme Court examined a dispute involving marital property located in Switzerland. The lower courts had returned a counterclaim concerning foreign real estate, reasoning that the relevant claims had to be brought before a court in the country where the property was located.
The Supreme Court rejected that approach. It explained that claims for division of marital property do not fall within the exclusive jurisdiction of foreign courts merely because the assets are situated outside Russia. Whether a Russian court has jurisdiction must be determined under the applicable rules of international jurisdiction.
A similar position was adopted in the Supreme Court's ruling of 20 July 2021, No. 53-KG21-5-K8. The Court explained that a claim for division of foreign marital real estate seeks to change the spouses' joint ownership regime. It is therefore incorrect to conclude that such a claim cannot be heard by a Russian court solely because the property is located abroad.
Accordingly, the fact that an apartment or house is located abroad does not, in itself, prevent a claim for its division from being brought before a Russian court. There must nevertheless be a valid jurisdictional basis under Russian procedural law.
Can Russian Courts Divide Funds Held in Foreign Bank Accounts?
A similar issue arises when one spouse holds funds in bank accounts outside Russia. In its ruling of 17 August 2010, No. 5-V10-51, the Russian Supreme Court considered a dispute in which one spouse sought division of funds held in the other spouse's bank accounts in the United States. The lower courts had refused the relevant claims, relying in part on the possibility of dividing the funds before an American court.
The Supreme Court found that reasoning to be incorrect. Russian civil procedure law does not assign claims for division of deposits held in foreign banks exclusively to foreign courts. However, the case also raised a separate evidentiary problem: the courts lacked sufficient information concerning the funds held in the accounts. The Supreme Court drew attention to inconsistencies in the lower courts' findings.
This ruling illustrates the importance of distinguishing between two questions: whether a court has jurisdiction to hear the claim and whether the existence of the assets to be divided has been proven. Relevant evidence may include bank statements, account-opening documents, transaction records, account balances and documents showing that the funds were acquired during the marriage.
How Is the Jurisdiction of Russian Courts Determined?
Where a dispute involves a foreign element, the rules of Chapter 44 of the Russian Civil Procedure Code and any applicable international treaties must be considered. Relevant factors include the defendant's place of residence, the existence of assets in Russia and other circumstances specified in Article 402 of the Civil Procedure Code. Depending on the case, the general rules of jurisdiction and international treaties on legal assistance may also be relevant.
The applicable substantive law must be considered separately. The fact that a Russian court has jurisdiction does not necessarily mean that Russian family law governs the spouses' property relations. Under Article 161 of the Russian Family Code, the applicable law is primarily determined by the spouses' common place of residence or, where they no longer share one, their last common place of residence. Other circumstances, including the terms of a prenuptial or marital agreement, may also be relevant.
What Difficulties Can Arise When Dividing Foreign Assets?
Establishing the existence and value of assets. It is necessary to determine which assets the spouses own, when and how they were acquired, whose name they are registered in and what they are worth. Obtaining documents from foreign banks and property registers may present a separate challenge.
Application of foreign law. If the spouses' matrimonial property relations are governed by the law of another country, the Russian court may need to establish the content of the relevant foreign legal provisions.
Prenuptial and marital agreements. Where the spouses have entered into an agreement regulating their property rights or the jurisdiction of courts, its terms may affect the litigation strategy. The validity of the agreement, the applicable law and the permissible scope of any jurisdiction clause must be assessed.
Recognition and enforcement of judgments. Even if a Russian court divides foreign real estate, the authorities of the country where the property is located are not automatically required to register a transfer of ownership on the basis of the Russian judgment. Recognition is governed by the law of the country where the asset is situated and by any applicable international agreements. It may therefore be appropriate to consider alternatives to transferring a particular foreign asset to one spouse, including financial compensation, where permitted by the applicable law and the circumstances of the case.
What Should Be Considered Before Bringing Proceedings?
Where spouses own assets in several countries, it is important to identify the assets before filing a claim, determine which courts may have jurisdiction, establish the applicable law and assess whether a future judgment can be recognised in the country where the assets are located. In many cases, the prospects of enforcement are central to choosing an effective property division strategy.
Russian courts may hear certain disputes concerning the division of marital property located abroad, but the choice of jurisdiction should take into account not only the possibility of obtaining a judgment, but also whether that judgment can be given practical effect.
Where marital assets are located both in Russia and abroad, a legal assessment before litigation can help determine where proceedings should be brought and what effect a judgment may have in different jurisdictions.